murphyandhislaw

reading list

A Scanner Darkly

Philip K. Dick

published: 1977, read: 5/27/24
220 pages, genre: Sci-Fi
rating: 6.75/10, normalized: 6.389/10
-0.458σ worse than average
-0.252σ or -0.235/10 worse than average in Sci-Fi genre
-0.956σ or -0.532/10 worse than average by Philip K. Dick

The premise of the plot is dramatic irony, but I’m not too captivated by the texture of the setting. The drug stuff is appreciably accurate unlike many other novels which try to grapple w/addiction and the mania of the accompanying lifestyle portrayed by folks who don’t seem to have had a credible front or back row seat to what that’s like. But the combination of the irony and drug dystopia alone doesn’t transcend. The book is rife with highs, mania, bad trips, ODs and more. The book correctly, IMO, captures the inescapable damage innate to addiction, as well as the weird aura present about a lot of rehabs lol.

Brutal author's note at the end which reads with cold indifference towards "drug misuse" as a decision rather than a disease. Interesting gritty take from Dicky here considering he had a front row seat to the disease:

AUTHOR'S NOTE

This has been a novel about some people who were punished entirely too much for what they did. They wanted to have a good time, but they were like children playing in the street; they could see one after another of them being killed--run over, maimed, destroyed--but they continued to play anyhow. We really all were very happy for a while, sitting around not toiling but just bullshitting and playing, but it was for such a terrible brief time, and then the punishment was beyond belief: even when we could see it, we could not believe it. For example, while I was writing this I learned that the person on whom the character Jerry Fabin is based killed himself. My friend on whom I based the character Ernie Luckman died before I began the novel. For a while I myself was one of these children playing in the street; I was, like the rest of them, trying to play instead of being grown up, and I was punished. I am on the list below, which is a list of those to whom this novel is dedicated, and what became of each.

Drug misuse is not a disease, it is a decision, like the decision to step out in front of a moving car. You would call that not a disease but an error in judgment. When a bunch of people begin to do it, it is a social error, a life-style. In this particular life-style the motto is "Be happy now because tomorrow you are dying," but the dying begins almost at once, and the happiness is a memory. It is, then, only a speeding up, an intensifying, of the ordinary human existence. It is not different from your life-style, it is only faster. It all takes place in days or weeks or months instead of years. "Take the cash and let the credit go," as Villon said in 1460. But that is a mistake if the cash is a penny and the credit a whole lifetime. There is no moral in this novel; it is not bourgeois; it does not say they were wrong to play when they should have toiled; it just tells what the consequences were. In Greek drama they were beginning, as a society, to discover science, which means causal law. Here in this novel there is Nemesis: not fate, because any one of us could have chosen to stop playing in the street, but, as I narrate from the deepest part of my life and heart, a dreadful Nemesis for those who kept on playing. I myself, I am not a character in this novel; I am the novel. So, though, was our entire nation at this time. This novel is about more people than I knew personally. Some we all read about in the newspapers. It was, this sitting around with our buddies and bullshitting while making tape recordings, the bad decision of the decade, the sixties, both in and out of the establishment. And nature cracked down on us. We were forced to stop by things dreadful.

If there was any "sin," it was that these people wanted to keep on having a good time forever, and were punished for that, but, as I say, I feel that, if so, the punishment was far too great, and I prefer to think of it only in a Greek or morally neutral way, as mere science, as deterministic impartial cause-and-effect. I loved them all. Here is the list, to whom I dedicate my love:

To Gaylene – deceased
To Ray – deceased
To Francy – permanent psychosis
To Kathy permanent –brain damage
To Jim – deceased
To Val – massive permanent brain damage
To Nancy – permanent psychosis
To Joanne – permanent brain damage
To Maren – deceased
To Nick – deceased To Terry – deceased
To Dennis – deceased
To Phil – permanent pancreatic damage
To Sue – permanent vascular damage
To Jerri – permanent psychosis and vascular damage
. . . and so forth.

In Memoriam. These were comrades whom I had; there are no better. They remain in my mind, and the enemy will never be forgiven. The "enemy" was their mistake in playing. Let them all play again, in some other way, and let them be happy.

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
5/27/24Philip K. DickA Scanner Darkly2201977Sci-Fi6.7506.389
1/29/25Hubert Selby Jr.Requiem for a Dream2881978Fiction7.5007.222
characterization of addictionreferenced
6/14/24Philip K. DickUbik2411969Sci-Fi6.5006.111
6/14/24Philip K. DickThe Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch2901964Sci-Fi7.5007.222
6/2/24Philip K. DickFlow My Tears, the Policeman Said2591974Sci-Fi7.0636.736
5/22/24Philip K. DickDo Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?2741968Sci-Fi8.0007.778
9/24/26Osamu DazaiNo Longer Human1771948Fiction7.6507.389
characterization of addiction
1/25/26Jon FosseA New Name
Septology (3)
2282021Fiction7.0006.667
characterization of addiction
1/24/26Jon FosseThe Other Name
Septology (1)
3512019Fiction6.5006.111
characterization of addiction
1/24/26Jon FosseI is Another
Septology (2)
2712020Fiction6.8336.481
characterization of addiction
8/3/25John MurryA Short History of Decay: Sea of Cortez522016Graphic Novel8.0057.783
characterization of addiction
5/31/25Gillian FlynnSharp Objects2522006Fiction7.0006.667
characterization of addiction
1/21/25Kaveh AkbarMartyr!3522024Fiction7.7507.500
characterization of addiction
Tommy A.
10/30/24David Foster WallaceInfinite Jest14511996Fiction10.00010.000
characterization of addiction
8/9/24John LanganThe Fisherman2632016Horror7.8337.593
characterization of addiction
8/5/24Brian O'RaleighPassage to Inis Mór3052020Fiction7.7507.500
characterization of addiction
Grandpa
6/6/24Philip K. DickVALIS3071981Psychology7.8757.639
Alex W.
5/25/24Vladimir NabokovPale Fire3011962Ergodic10.00010.000
"cells interlinked, cells"
7/13/22Stephen KingThe Outsider5762018Horror6.5006.111
characterization of addiction
9/1/17Hunter S. ThompsonFear and Loathing in Las Vegas2251971Fiction6.0005.556
schizo
Alex W.
10/10/16William FaulknerThe Sound and the Fury3261927Fiction8.2508.056
characterization of addiction
Steg
9/21/26Yoko OgawaThe Memory Police2881994Sci-Fi4.0003.333
7/1/26Vernor VingeA Fire Upon the Deep6261992Sci-Fi7.2506.944
12/31/25Cixin LiuTo Hold Up the Sky3362021Sci-Fi6.7006.333
11/9/25Greg EganDistress
Subjective Cosmology Cycle (3)
3421998Sci-Fi7.0006.667
10/29/25Greg EganQuarantine
Subjective Cosmology Cycle (1)
2801992Sci-Fi7.7507.500
10/15/25Robert A. HeinleinStarship Troopers2901987Sci-Fi8.0007.778
Charlie J.
9/14/25Kurt VonnegutPlayer Piano2961952Sci-Fi6.6506.278
9/10/25George Orwell19843281949Sci-Fi7.7507.500
9/7/25Yevgeny ZamyatinWe2261924Sci-Fi7.0006.667
9/6/25Aldous HuxleyBrave New World2881932Sci-Fi7.2506.944
8/11/25Greg EganDiaspora3761997Sci-Fi8.0007.778
thesephist
8/11/25Olga RavnThe Employees1262020Sci-Fi5.5005.000
6/8/25Helen PhillipsThe Need2722019Sci-Fi7.1506.833
4/7/25Pierce BrownLight Bringer
Red Rising Saga (6)
7042023Sci-Fi7.7507.500
Thomas
3/27/25Pierce BrownDark Age
Red Rising Saga (5)
7842019Sci-Fi7.5007.222
Thomas
3/18/25Pierce BrownIron Gold
Red Rising Saga (4)
5962018Sci-Fi6.0005.556
Thomas
3/18/25qntmFine Structure3862021Sci-Fi7.0006.667
3/13/25Pierce BrownMorning Star
Red Rising Saga (3)
5182016Sci-Fi5.1254.583
Thomas
3/5/25Pierce BrownGolden Son
Red Rising Saga (2)
4642015Sci-Fi5.8755.417
Thomas
2/28/25Pierce BrownRed Rising
Red Rising Saga (1)
3822014Sci-Fi5.5005.000
Thomas
2/18/25Hugh HowieDust
Silo (3)
4802013Sci-Fi7.0006.667
Jack M.
2/14/25Hugh HowieShift
Silo (2)
5762013Sci-Fi7.2506.944
Jack M.
2/9/25Hugh HowieWool
Silo (1)
5922011Sci-Fi7.0006.667
Jack M.
2/1/25Matt DinnimanDungeon Crawler Carl
Dungeon Crawler Carl (1)
4642020Sci-Fi6.0005.556
Noah
1/15/25qntmEd1442021Sci-Fi7.0006.667
1/13/25qntmValuable Humans in Transit and Other Stories1072022Sci-Fi7.3757.083
1/3/25Isaac AsimovNightfall and Other Stories3521969Sci-Fi6.7376.374
12/7/24Dan SimmonsThe Rise of Endymion
Hyperion Cantos (4)
5791997Sci-Fi6.0005.556
11/30/24Dan SimmonsEndymion
Hyperion Cantos (3)
4411996Sci-Fi6.2505.833
11/30/24George R.R. MartinDreamsongs: The Second Kind of Loneliness6701972Sci-Fi7.2506.944
11/24/24Dan SimmonsThe Fall of Hyperion
Hyperion Cantos (2)
5171990Sci-Fi8.2508.056
11/16/24Dan SimmonsHyperion
Hyperion Cantos (1)
4821989Sci-Fi8.0257.806
9/6/24Alastair ReynoldsEversion3522022Sci-Fi7.0836.759
Nick W.
9/6/24Greg EganYou and Whose Army?341998Sci-Fi6.7506.389
9/5/24Greg EganPlanck Dive231998Sci-Fi9.2509.167
9/4/24Paul AndersonTau Zero2321970Sci-Fi7.2506.944
roon
8/29/24José SaramagoBlindness3521995Sci-Fi7.0006.667
8/28/24Margaret AtwoodOryx and Crake
MaddAddam (1)
4002003Sci-Fi6.0005.556
Steg
8/1/24Ursula K. Le GuinThe Telling
Hainish Cycle (8)
4162000Sci-Fi6.5006.111
7/28/24Ursula K. Le GuinFour Ways to Forgiveness
Hainish Cycle (7)
3201995Sci-Fi5.5005.000
7/26/24Ursula K. Le GuinThe Left Hand of Darkness
Hainish Cycle (4)
3371969Sci-Fi7.5007.222
7/26/24Ursula K. Le GuinThe Word for World is Forest
Hainish Cycle (5)
1891972Sci-Fi7.7507.500
7/16/24Ursula K. Le GuinCity of Illusions
Hainish Cycle (3)
1991967Sci-Fi6.7506.389
7/10/24Ursula K. Le GuinRocannon's World
Hainish Cycle (1)
2581966Sci-Fi6.5006.111
7/10/24Ursula K. Le GuinPlanet of Exile
Hainish Cycle (2)
1351966Sci-Fi6.0005.556
6/30/24Ursula K. Le GuinThe Dispossessed
Hainish Cycle (6)
2841974Sci-Fi7.8507.611
6/13/24Neal StephensonSeveneves8802015Sci-Fi8.7508.611
5/12/24Italo CalvinoCosmicomics1791965Sci-Fi7.0296.699
Will Liff.
1/13/24Iain BanksConsider Phlebas
Culture (1)
4711987Sci-Fi6.2505.833
roon
1/1/24Arthur C. ClarkeFountains of Paradise2631979Sci-Fi7.0006.667
12/17/23James S.A. CoreyCaliban's War
The Expanse (2)
6052012Sci-Fi5.0004.444
Charlie J.
10/28/23James S.A. CoreyLeviathan Wakes
The Expanse (1)
5772011Sci-Fi6.7506.389
Charlie J.
10/14/23Roger ZelaznyLord of Light3081967Sci-Fi6.7506.389
8/23/23Adrian TchaikovskyCage of Souls6382019Sci-Fi8.0007.778
Alex W.
7/15/23Gene WolfeFifth Head of Cerberus2441972Sci-Fi9.0838.981
6/18/23VariousObsolescence3602023Sci-Fi6.0005.556
1/31/23Greg EganPermutation City
Subjective Cosmology Cycle (2)
2751994Sci-Fi6.7506.389
1/29/23George SaundersEscape from Spiderhead102010Sci-Fi7.7507.500
1/27/23Robert A. HeinleinThe Moon is a Harsh Mistress3821966Sci-Fi8.2508.056
1/18/23Adrian TchaikovskyChildren of Ruin
Children of Time (2)
4752019Sci-Fi6.7506.389
Alex W.
1/15/23Blake CrouchDark Matter3682017Sci-Fi7.0006.667
Nick W.
1/13/23Adrian TchaikovskyChildren of Time
Children of Time (1)
5132015Sci-Fi7.0006.667
Alex W.
1/11/23Ted ChiangExhalation3682019Sci-Fi7.5007.222
1/8/23Joe HaldermanThe Forever War2361974Sci-Fi5.0004.444
10/27/22Cixin LiuDeaths End
Three Body Problem (3)
5922008Sci-Fi8.5008.333
Alex W.
10/17/22Cixin LiuThe Dark Forest
Three Body Problem (2)
4002008Sci-Fi9.0008.889
Alex W.
10/10/22Isaac AsimovSecond Foundation
Foundation (4)
2101953Sci-Fi6.5006.111
10/1/22Cixin LiuThe Three Body Problem
Three Body Problem (1)
3022008Sci-Fi8.0007.778
Alex W.
9/15/22Isaac AsimovFoundation
Foundation (3)
2551951Sci-Fi6.5006.111
9/11/22Isaac AsimovForward the Foundation
Foundation (2)
4171993Sci-Fi7.0006.667
9/5/22Frank HerbertDune Messiah
Dune (2)
2561969Sci-Fi7.0006.667
9/5/22Frank HerbertChildren of Dune
Dune (3)
4441976Sci-Fi6.5006.111
8/6/22Frank HerbertDune
Dune (1)
4121965Sci-Fi7.5007.222
7/13/22Isaac AsimovPrelude to Foundation
Foundation (1)
4481988Sci-Fi6.5006.111
10/13/16Ernest ClineReady Player One3842011Sci-Fi6.5006.111
8/16/16Douglas AdamsThe Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy2241979Sci-Fi6.5006.111
4/20/16Orson Scott CardEnder's Game
Ender (1)
3241985Sci-Fi7.7507.500
6/28/13Eoin ColferThe Supernaturalist2902004Sci-Fi7.0006.667