murphyandhislaw

reading list

Fablehaven (5): Keys to the Demon Prison

Brandon Mull

published: 2010, read: 1/20/15
593 pages, genre: Fantasy
rating: 6.5/10, normalized: 6.111/10
-0.684σ worse than average
-0.736σ or -0.771/10 worse than average in Fantasy genre
-1.029σ or -0.3/10 worse than average by Brandon Mull

"Grandpa and Grandma Larsen are alive..." which kind of sums up the reason why this book stays in the YA ceiling of goodness for me. Most of the characters have plot armor. It's still a great adventure series re: Indiana Jones, but it's limited by the narrative's unwillingness to friggin kill off characters to make the threats of the demons real.

This book in particular was a lot of loose ends being tied up I felt. The grand infinity war battle wasn't compelling since the threat was almost purely existential at this point. Not for a second was I worried about anybody dying, nor did the threat ever seem particularly "real" (in the scope of a YA fantasy series). The scope got too big (world safety threatened) without the author ever actually being willing to kill anyone. Whereas in the 4th book in Wyrmroost, people were getting KO'd and the "threat" of violence seemed a lot more real.

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
1/20/15Brandon MullKeys to the Demon Prison
Fablehaven (5)
5932010Fantasy6.5006.111
12/2/14Brandon MullSecrets of the Dragon Sanctuary
Fablehaven (4)
5352009Fantasy7.2506.944
10/30/14Brandon MullGrip of the Shadow Plague
Fablehaven (3)
4772008Fantasy6.7506.389
10/14/14Brandon MullRise of the Evening Star
Fablehaven (2)
4562007Fantasy7.0006.667
8/1/14Brandon MullFablehaven
Fablehaven (1)
3512006Fantasy6.5006.111
12/18/25Adrian TchaikovskyHouse of Open Wounds
The Tyrant Philosophers (2)
6062023Fantasy7.6257.361
Alex W.
12/7/25Adrian TchaikovskyCity of Last Chances
The Tyrant Philosophers (1)
5002022Fantasy7.6257.361
Alex W.
7/30/25Ken LiuSpeaking Bones
Dandelion Dynasty (4)
10472022Fantasy8.0007.778
7/6/25Ken LiuThe Veiled Throne
Dandelion Dynasty (3)
10082021Fantasy6.9006.556
6/16/25Ken LiuThe Wall of Storms
Dandelion Dynasty (2)
8802016Fantasy7.5007.222
5/31/25Ken LiuGrace of Kings
Dandelion Dynasty (1)
6562015Fantasy6.2505.833
12/19/24J.R.R. TolkienThe Return of the King
Lord of the Rings (3)
4321955Fantasy8.0007.778
Ginny
12/17/24J.R.R. TolkienThe Two Towers
Lord of the Rings (2)
3521954Fantasy7.7507.500
Ginny
12/14/24J.R.R. TolkienThe Fellowship Of The Ring
Lord of the Rings (1)
4321954Fantasy7.0006.667
Ginny
11/11/24Patrick RothfussThe Wise Man's Fear
The Kingkiller Chronicle (2)
9942011Fantasy6.7506.389
Jeff W.
10/31/24Patrick RothfussThe Name of the Wind
The Kingkiller Chronicle (1)
6622007Fantasy7.6257.361
Jeff W.
8/25/24George R.R. MartinA Dance with Dragons
A Song of Ice and Fire (5)
10562011Fantasy7.5007.222
3/19/24George R.R. MartinA Feast for Crows
A Song of Ice and Fire (4)
7532005Fantasy8.1257.917
2/8/24Rebecca YarrosEmpyrean
The Fourth Wing (1)
5122023Fantasy3.8333.148
12/1/23George R.R. MartinA Storm of Swords
A Song of Ice and Fire (3)
9732000Fantasy9.3009.222
10/3/23George R.R. MartinA Clash of Kings
A Song of Ice and Fire (2)
7681999Fantasy6.0835.648
9/6/23George R.R. MartinA Game of Thrones
A Song of Ice and Fire (1)
6941996Fantasy9.2509.167
8/11/23Joe AbercrombieLast Argument of Kings
First Law (3)
6742008Fantasy9.1259.028
Jack H.
8/2/23Joe AbercrombieBefore They Are Hanged
First Law (2)
5772007Fantasy8.1677.963
Jack H.
7/27/23Joe AbercrombieThe Blade Itself
First Law (1)
4362006Fantasy8.0007.778
Jack H.
7/19/23Gene WolfeThe Shadow of the Torturer
The Book of the New Sun (1)
3031980Fantasy6.1255.694
6/13/23Brandon SandersonWarbreaker6692006Fantasy5.5005.000
Charlie J.
3/26/23Brandon SandersonWords of Radiance
Stormlight Archives (2)
10802014Fantasy6.5006.111
Charlie J.
2/20/23Brandon SandersonThe Way of Kings
Stormlight Archives (1)
10082010Fantasy7.8507.611
Charlie J.
2/4/23V.E. SchwabbA Darker Shade of Magic
Shades of Magic (1)
4012015Fantasy5.0004.444
11/5/16Brandon SandersonThe Final Empire
Mistborn (1)
5412006Fantasy7.7507.500
Charlie J.
9/30/16Henry NeffThe Red Winter
Tapestry (5)
6532014Fantasy8.0007.778
Charlie J.
9/21/16Henry NeffThe Maelstrom
Tapestry (4)
4802012Fantasy8.5008.333
Charlie J.
9/14/16Henry NeffThe Fiend and the Forge
Tapestry (3)
5622010Fantasy8.5008.333
Charlie J.
7/14/16Henry NeffThe Second Siege
Tapestry (2)
5122008Fantasy7.5007.222
Charlie J.
6/5/16Henry NeffThe Hound of Rowan
Tapestry (1)
4392007Fantasy6.5006.111
Charlie J.
3/4/16Michael ScottThe Enchantress
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (6)
4162012Fantasy7.2506.944
2/2/16Michael ScottThe Warlock
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (5)
4002011Fantasy7.5007.222
11/10/15Michael ScottThe Necromancer
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (4)
4162010Fantasy7.5007.222
4/20/15Michael ScottThe Sorceress
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (3)
4832009Fantasy7.0006.667
3/13/15Michael ScottThe Magician
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (2)
4612008Fantasy7.0006.667
7/15/14Michael ScottThe Alchemist
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (1)
3752007Fantasy6.7506.389
7/25/13Eoin ColferAirman4122007Fantasy7.5007.222