murphyandhislaw

reading list

The Fourth Wing (1): Empyrean

Rebecca Yarros

published: 2023, read: 2/8/24
512 pages, genre: Fantasy
rating: 3.833/10, normalized: 3.148/10
-3.104σ worse than average
-3.284σ or -3.438/10 worse than average in Fantasy genre

Yet another book I'm reading because of a girl. It was pitched to me as "Harry Potter meets Twilight" so you can already tell this shit probably sucks. I obviously cannot tell her that I think so (I could, however, just not read the book, but I'm literally so pathetic that I'm delaying good dragon smut book (A Feast for Crows) with this commercial YAF dragon smut. So far it's only slightly less insufferable than R.F. Kuang.

"People die all too often here for them to just hand out ranks" doesn't make any sense. If anything, being shorthanded on military staff would imply inflation of rank.

Kind of annoying that it's apparently obvious that Griffins have a hard time breathing at high altitude because they're lion + eagle (famously bad at breathing at high altitude). Apparently dragons have no issue with this (no citation provided because it's fantasy and this is just a shitty plot point to motivate a +10 points to Gryffindor moment)

Justifying an attack on an outpost village because the bad guys (bad because we said so, trust us :tm:) keep denying the peace deals (bc u keep raiding them) is such a lazy and politically bankrupt backdrop for a nation at war, from the narrative perspective of a supposed historian. These things aren't supposed to matter, dear reader, what you need to be focused on is all the sucking and fucking that's going on in the barracks. This book is so horny. It's 100% the genre of tiktok smut for women who are too goody-goody to watch porn. Instead we get 500 pages of "cool, meek, but against-all-odds-the-hero military woman who gets dommed by her now-hunk childhood best friend who is so muscular and chiseled and has stubble uWu"

I feel like I need an adult after reading the first few chapters – no idea how people recommend this book to one another, it feels like trying to compare notes on Fifty Shades but she rec'd it to me soooooo ¯\(ツ)/¯

Would you be surprised if I said the main character is dumb?

would you be surprised if I said that the combat is dumb?

would you be surprised if I said that the male characters are dumb?

would you be surprised if I said that the sex is dumb?

would you be surprised if I said that the word "macabre" has been used 4x so far?

helpless female protag is empowered when wrong person tries to take care of her, but it's hot when right guy becomes overprotective. actually very true to form and woman-coded ig (playing to a masc perception of a shitty female protagonist, not sure what this means just yet...)

macabre mentioned dude this suck, why am I doing this to myself

young men should never read the word "clit" it's not meant to be read by us

Subloxate is the new macabre. Similar to a sandolanche, Yarros employs a clitoralanche and a cocklanche, and a gliding tongue-lanche. The first 350 pages are really just a cringe copy/paste of Eragon + fucking.

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
2/8/24Rebecca YarrosEmpyrean
The Fourth Wing (1)
5122023Fantasy3.8333.148
12/18/25Adrian TchaikovskyHouse of Open Wounds
The Tyrant Philosophers (2)
6062023Fantasy7.6257.361
Alex W.
12/7/25Adrian TchaikovskyCity of Last Chances
The Tyrant Philosophers (1)
5002022Fantasy7.6257.361
Alex W.
7/30/25Ken LiuSpeaking Bones
Dandelion Dynasty (4)
10472022Fantasy8.0007.778
7/6/25Ken LiuThe Veiled Throne
Dandelion Dynasty (3)
10082021Fantasy6.9006.556
6/16/25Ken LiuThe Wall of Storms
Dandelion Dynasty (2)
8802016Fantasy7.5007.222
5/31/25Ken LiuGrace of Kings
Dandelion Dynasty (1)
6562015Fantasy6.2505.833
12/19/24J.R.R. TolkienThe Return of the King
Lord of the Rings (3)
4321955Fantasy8.0007.778
Ginny
12/17/24J.R.R. TolkienThe Two Towers
Lord of the Rings (2)
3521954Fantasy7.7507.500
Ginny
12/14/24J.R.R. TolkienThe Fellowship Of The Ring
Lord of the Rings (1)
4321954Fantasy7.0006.667
Ginny
11/11/24Patrick RothfussThe Wise Man's Fear
The Kingkiller Chronicle (2)
9942011Fantasy6.7506.389
Jeff W.
10/31/24Patrick RothfussThe Name of the Wind
The Kingkiller Chronicle (1)
6622007Fantasy7.6257.361
Jeff W.
8/25/24George R.R. MartinA Dance with Dragons
A Song of Ice and Fire (5)
10562011Fantasy7.5007.222
3/19/24George R.R. MartinA Feast for Crows
A Song of Ice and Fire (4)
7532005Fantasy8.1257.917
12/1/23George R.R. MartinA Storm of Swords
A Song of Ice and Fire (3)
9732000Fantasy9.3009.222
10/3/23George R.R. MartinA Clash of Kings
A Song of Ice and Fire (2)
7681999Fantasy6.0835.648
9/6/23George R.R. MartinA Game of Thrones
A Song of Ice and Fire (1)
6941996Fantasy9.2509.167
8/11/23Joe AbercrombieLast Argument of Kings
First Law (3)
6742008Fantasy9.1259.028
Jack H.
8/2/23Joe AbercrombieBefore They Are Hanged
First Law (2)
5772007Fantasy8.1677.963
Jack H.
7/27/23Joe AbercrombieThe Blade Itself
First Law (1)
4362006Fantasy8.0007.778
Jack H.
7/19/23Gene WolfeThe Shadow of the Torturer
The Book of the New Sun (1)
3031980Fantasy6.1255.694
6/13/23Brandon SandersonWarbreaker6692006Fantasy5.5005.000
Charlie J.
3/26/23Brandon SandersonWords of Radiance
Stormlight Archives (2)
10802014Fantasy6.5006.111
Charlie J.
2/20/23Brandon SandersonThe Way of Kings
Stormlight Archives (1)
10082010Fantasy7.8507.611
Charlie J.
2/4/23V.E. SchwabbA Darker Shade of Magic
Shades of Magic (1)
4012015Fantasy5.0004.444
11/5/16Brandon SandersonThe Final Empire
Mistborn (1)
5412006Fantasy7.7507.500
Charlie J.
9/30/16Henry NeffThe Red Winter
Tapestry (5)
6532014Fantasy8.0007.778
Charlie J.
9/21/16Henry NeffThe Maelstrom
Tapestry (4)
4802012Fantasy8.5008.333
Charlie J.
9/14/16Henry NeffThe Fiend and the Forge
Tapestry (3)
5622010Fantasy8.5008.333
Charlie J.
7/14/16Henry NeffThe Second Siege
Tapestry (2)
5122008Fantasy7.5007.222
Charlie J.
6/5/16Henry NeffThe Hound of Rowan
Tapestry (1)
4392007Fantasy6.5006.111
Charlie J.
3/4/16Michael ScottThe Enchantress
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (6)
4162012Fantasy7.2506.944
2/2/16Michael ScottThe Warlock
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (5)
4002011Fantasy7.5007.222
11/10/15Michael ScottThe Necromancer
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (4)
4162010Fantasy7.5007.222
4/20/15Michael ScottThe Sorceress
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (3)
4832009Fantasy7.0006.667
3/13/15Michael ScottThe Magician
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (2)
4612008Fantasy7.0006.667
1/20/15Brandon MullKeys to the Demon Prison
Fablehaven (5)
5932010Fantasy6.5006.111
12/2/14Brandon MullSecrets of the Dragon Sanctuary
Fablehaven (4)
5352009Fantasy7.2506.944
10/30/14Brandon MullGrip of the Shadow Plague
Fablehaven (3)
4772008Fantasy6.7506.389
10/14/14Brandon MullRise of the Evening Star
Fablehaven (2)
4562007Fantasy7.0006.667
8/1/14Brandon MullFablehaven
Fablehaven (1)
3512006Fantasy6.5006.111
7/15/14Michael ScottThe Alchemist
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (1)
3752007Fantasy6.7506.389
7/25/13Eoin ColferAirman4122007Fantasy7.5007.222