murphyandhislaw

reading list

Love's Work

Gillian Rose

published: 1995, read: 4/17/26
176 pages, genre: Biography
rating: 7.85/10, normalized: 7.611/10
0.541σ better than average
1.251σ or 0.833/10 better than average in Biography genre

Very fascinating philosophical memoir about the nature of love, being hurt, and dying. It's scatterbrained but in a way which I don't at all mind. It's like pulling back the veil on someone's soul.

les vrais paradis sont les paradis qu’on a perdus

– Proust quote about "the true paradises are the paradises that one has lost"

Keep your mind in hell and despair not

In personal life, people have absolute power over each other, whereas in professional life, beyond the terms of the contract, people have authority, the power to make one another comply in ways which may be perceived as legitimate or illegitimate. In personal life, regardless of any covenant, one party may initiate a unilateral and fundamental change in the terms of relating without renegotiating them, and further, refusing even to acknowledge the change.

Imagine how a beloved child or dog would respond, if the Lover turned away. There is no democracy in any love relation: only mercy. To be at someone's mercy is dialectical damage: they may be merciful and they may be merciless. Yet each party, woman, man, the child in each, and their child, is absolute power as well as absolute vulnerability. You may be less powerful than the whole world, but you are always more powerful than yourself

Full of bangers:

The three I harbour within me—body, soul and paraclete—press against the same triplicity in you.

this time I want to do a different differently. You may be weaker than the whole world that you were always stronger than yourself. Let me send my power against my power. So what if I die. Let me discover what it is that I want in fear from love.

.

gestures of histrionic largesse

.

this medieval tale (of King Arthur, who loses Guinevere to lance a lot) contains Merlin‘s wisdom about the rule of reason. It tells what happened when a sovereign people (“the king“) without coercion decree law for themselves. Their humanity is forgotten, and so will be the law. Sadness is the condition of the king. For he has to experience his power and his vulnerability, his love and his violence, within and without the law.

let’s play a game called BAP or Gillian:

This decision by the intellectuals that reason itself has ruined modern life, and should be dethroned and banned in the name of its silenced others, is comparable to the decision to stop small children, girls and boys, from playing with guns, pugnacious video games, or any violent toys. This brutally sincere, enlightened probity, which thinks it will stop war and aggression, in effect aggravates their propensity. This decision evinces loss of trust in the way that play (fairy stories, terrifying films) teaches the difference between fantasy and actuality. The child who is able to explore that border will feel safe in experiencing vio-lent, inner, emotional conflict, and will acquire compassion for other people. The child who is locked away from aggressive experiment and play will be left terrified and paralysed by its emotions, unable to release or face them, for they may destroy the world and himself or herself. The censor aggravates the syndrome she seeks to alleviate; she seeks to rub out in others the border which has been effaced inside herself.

.

Does not all writing, even if it claims at Gelassenheit—to let things be—arrogate such illegitimate authority

. Kant, father of enlightenment, born out of reformation to its logical end of discerning unrevealed religion in the form of rationalism:

Immanuel Kant was an ardent Pietist, a follower of that Protestant Counter-Reformation, the Reformation of the Reformation. He knew that, since Luther, authority and scepticism keep changing places: one person's authority is another's scepticism. Descartes drew his voie d'examen from Calvinism; in turn, the French Counter-Reformation drew its fideism from Descartes's scepticism.

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
4/17/26Gillian RoseLove's Work1761995Biography7.8507.611
8/26/26Stefan ZweigBeware of Pity3921939Fiction7.8507.611
Love is work
7/20/26Thomas MannThe Magic Mountain7061924Fiction7.3007.000
Secretly philosophy
Scott
4/16/26Bronze Age PervertBronze Age Mindset1982018Non-Fiction5.0004.444
knowing the good by the bad
4/2/26Roberto BolañoPosthumous Stories1602025Fiction7.0006.667
posthumous
12/18/25John MiltonDe Doctrina Christiana5641645Non-FictionN/AN/A
posthumous
10/22/25Milan KunderaThe Unbearable Lightness of Being3141984Fiction8.2008.000
Secretly philosophy
Ben Roth
7/30/25John MiltonAreopagitica and Other Political Writings of John Milton4721644Non-FictionN/AN/A
knowing the good by the bad
4/15/25David Foster WallaceThe Pale King6362011Fiction7.7507.500
posthumous
4/9/24Roberto Bolaño2666: A Novel9122004Fiction8.1507.944
posthumous
roon
10/25/26Tara WestoverEducated3522018Biography6.5006.111
Seth R.
9/9/26Jean-Dominique Bauby The Diving Bell and the Butterfly1321997Biography7.0006.667
Scott
7/8/26Primo LeviThe Truce2531963Biography7.5007.222
7/5/26William HayleyThe Life of Milton: Conjectures on the origin of Paradise Lost3381799BiographyN/AN/A
3/26/26Bert GhezziThe Voices of the Saints8162000BiographyN/AN/A
FTR
3/9/26David Masson1608-1639
The Life of John Milton (1)
8741881BiographyN/AN/A
3/9/26David Masson1638-1642
The Life of John Milton (2)
1501881BiographyN/AN/A
2/19/26Ed AtkinsFlower962025Biography7.0006.667
7/15/25Vladimir NabokovSpeak, Memory: An Autobiography Revisited3361989Biography6.5506.167
6/18/25Brian ReedS-Town2542017Biography6.3215.913
Jessika
5/5/25Jason EvertSaint John Paul the Great: His Five Loves3002014Biography7.0006.667
Emma
4/12/25Walter IsaacsonElon Musk6882023Biography5.5005.000
Leigh
8/30/24David CrowThe Pale-faced Lie3422019Biography8.0007.778
Crow
1/23/22Matthew McConaugheyGreenlights3042020Biography7.2506.944
Jack M.
1/9/22Michael LewisThe Undoing Project3682016Biography7.7507.500
7/9/18Michael LewisFlash Boys2882014Biography7.0006.667
Jack M.