murphyandhislaw

reading list

Which as You Know Means Violence

Philippa Snow

published: 2022, read: 3/2/26
120 pages, genre: Non-Fiction
rating: 7.875/10, normalized: 7.639/10
0.565σ better than average
0.511σ or 0.433/10 better than average in Non-Fiction genre

For reasons I have not yet had unraveled for me by a qualified therapist, I have always been drawn towards extremity in art and culture, reasoning that an intellectual shock can restore clarity to the mind

Title comes from a voicemail left by Hunter S. Thompson for Johnny Knoxville in which he said:

What I need is a 40,000-candlepower illumination grenade. Big, bright bastards, that's what I need. See if you can get them for me. I might be coming to Baton Rouge ... and if I do I will call you, because I will be looking to have some fun, which as you know usually means violence.

Oh my God, I forgot that I saw exactly just this scene from Blue velvet recreated by Lynch for it had traumatized him so until Snow mentioned it in passing.

Dullness tends to be associated with psychic pain because something that's dull or opaque fails to provide enough stimulation to distract people form some other, deeper type of pain that is always there if only in an ambient, low-level way – DFW

TIL cofounder of Vice is the founder of the Proud boys

qua British lads hit each other with a chair:

Later in the video, when the first boy is on the ground after the second round of pain, the other keeps the promise made by the earlier kiss by cradling him, Pieta-like, the two men touching skin to skin. The willing victim seems to ahve experienced a transformative agony, his breathlessness and wide eyes closer to an erotic expression than a hurt one.

The prose are rather good; the subject is inventive; the research and pop cultural/memetic anecdotes are compelling – some of the in between the lines artsy-fartsy things about externally-inflected pain being instrumental to the feminine psyche/experience and its constituent trans-affirming surgery strike me as dissonant even if you share all of the author's priors:

The most interesting way to use self-injury as a way to explore one's gender is to act in opposition to what might otherwise be expected of you – to be a beautiful sorority girl who plays the stuntman, or a stuntman who displays himself like a beautiful sorority girl, or a trans woman who not only shares her transition with her audience, but makes it obvious that her ordeal was not pitiable or ugly, but heroic.

c.f. Buster Keaton with Harmony Korine of Gummo:

Sex and love are only other types of suffering

Of Bataille's la petite mort:

Bataille's theory about the proximity of death and orgasm, both offering flashbulb glimpses of an unfamiliar world, is correct: no two experiences make us feel more like passengers in our physical bodies, moving us inexorably towards an endpoint that feels uncontrollable and overwhelming (or, as Bataille would say, "violent").

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
3/2/26Philippa SnowWhich as You Know Means Violence1202022Non-Fiction7.8757.639
11/10/26Pope Leo XIVI Am a Son of Saint Augustine1042026Non-Fiction7.2506.944
9/1/26Peter MurphyThrough the Heretical Lens (1)1922026Non-Fiction7.9507.722
7/3/26Arthur SewellA Study in Milton's Christian Doctrine2141939Non-Fiction8.7508.611
6/22/26W.B.C WatkinsAn Anatomy of Milton's Verse1461955Non-FictionN/AN/A
5/27/26John PeterA Critique of Paradise Lost1721970Non-FictionN/AN/A
5/18/26C.S. LewisA Preface to Paradise Lost1431942Non-FictionN/AN/A
4/16/26Bronze Age PervertBronze Age Mindset1982018Non-Fiction5.0004.444
4/3/26Mel RobbinsThe Let Them Theory3362024Non-Fiction6.0005.556
3/12/26F.T. PrinceThe Italian Element in Milton's Verse2081962Non-FictionN/AN/A
3/10/26Douglas BushParadise Lost in our Time1171957Non-FictionN/AN/A
3/8/26E.M.Y. TillyardStudies in Milton1761973Non-FictionN/AN/A
2/22/26Denys TurnerThe Darkness of God: Negativity in Christian Mysticism2921998Non-Fiction7.7507.500
2/17/26Isabel MacCaffrey Paradise Lost as “Myth”2291959Non-FictionN/AN/A
2/15/26Walter Curry ClydeMilton's Ontology Cosmogony and Physics2261957Non-FictionN/AN/A
2/6/26Williiam KerriganThe Sacred Complex2981983Non-FictionN/AN/A
1/27/26Thomas KranidasThe Fierce Equation1581965Non-FictionN/AN/A
1/24/26James WhalerCounterpoint and Symbol2261956Non-FictionN/AN/A
1/22/26Malcom RossPoetry & dogma2561954Non-FictionN/AN/A
1/18/26George ConklinBiblical Criticism and Heresy in Milton1371971Non-FictionN/AN/A
1/11/26Michael LiebThe Dialectics of Creation: Patterns of Birth & Regeneration2441969Non-FictionN/AN/A
1/8/26William G. MadsenFrom Shadowy Types to Truth2021967Non-FictionN/AN/A
1/5/26William EmpsonMilton's God2761961Non-FictionN/AN/A
12/18/25John MiltonDe Doctrina Christiana5641645Non-FictionN/AN/A
12/8/25Harold BloomThe Western Canon5281994Non-FictionN/AN/A
9/21/25Stanley FishSurprised by Sin: the Reader in Paradise Lost3641967Non-Fiction7.0006.667
9/18/25Geoffrey HartmanA Critic's Journey: Literary Reflections3401998Non-FictionN/AN/A
9/15/25Louis Martz20th Century Views: Milton, Paradise Lost: A Collection of Essays2091966Non-Fiction7.7507.500
8/8/25Samuel JohnsonThe Lives of English Poets5601779Non-FictionN/AN/A
8/2/25Balachandra RajanParadise Lost and the Seventeenth Century Reader1761947Non-FictionN/AN/A
7/30/25John MiltonAreopagitica and Other Political Writings of John Milton4721644Non-FictionN/AN/A
7/30/25A.J.A. WaldockParadise Lost: And Its Critics1601961Non-FictionN/AN/A
8/3/24Kim ZetterCountdown to Zero Day4062014Non-Fiction7.2506.944
7/2/23Samo BurjaThe Great Founder Theory1772020Non-Fiction6.7506.389
roon
2/2/23Peter LeesonThe Invisible Hook2882009Non-Fiction7.5007.222
Misha
4/10/22William JamesThe Varieties of Religious Experience2841902Non-Fiction7.5007.222
11/20/21Robert ReichJust Giving2562020Non-Fiction6.7506.389
10/15/18Bart D. EhrmanA Historical Introduction to the Early Christian Writings6082011Non-Fiction8.5008.333
7/14/17Robert GatesA Passion for Leadership2562016Non-Fiction8.0007.778
6/29/17Christopher McDougallBorn to Run3062009Non-Fiction7.7507.500
6/14/17Aleksandr SolzhenitsynThe Gulag Archipelago5281973Non-Fiction7.7507.500
9/26/16Martin PopsThe Metamorphosis of Shit361982Non-Fiction8.5008.333
8/14/15Marcus LuttrellLone Survivor3902007Non-Fiction7.2506.944