murphyandhislaw

reading list

The Lives of English Poets

Samuel Johnson

published: 1779, read: 8/8/25
560 pages, genre: Non-Fiction

"the third book coincided with Milton’s last days of sight and the seventh with the return of the king that had clouded him with discountenance; that he was offended by the licentious festivity of the Restoration (pp. 101)"

Sold PL for five pounds

In this sense, he may be ragarded as one of the greatest punk rockers of all time

"Milton’s republicanism was, I am afraid, founded in an envious hatred of greatness, and a sullen desire of independence; in petulance impatient of controul, and pride disdainful of superiority. He hated monarchs in the state, and prelates in the church; for he hated all whom he was required to obey. It is to be suspected, that his predominant desire was to destroy rather than establish, and that he felt not so much the love of liberty as repugnance to authority. "

but this does not jive with what he wrote. Though writing maketh not a man's behavior, clearly.

C.f. Johnson could not have known at the time the workings of DDC, but as Empson points out, his beliefs on obedience and conscience align much more closely with Eve than Adam

"“He though woman made only for obedience, and man only for rebellion”

Milton kind of an asshole

What we hope ever to do with ease, we may learn first to do with diligence. ... Milton never learned the art of doing little things with grace, he overlooked the milder excellence of suavity and softness, he was a lion that had no skill in dandling the Kid

Allegory of sin and death

“unskillful allegory appears to me one of the greatest faults of the poem"

"Our Language, says Addison, sunk under him. But the truth is, that, both in prose and verse, he had formed his style by a perverse and pedantic principle. He was desirous to use English words with a foreign idiom. This in all his prose is discovered and condemend; for there judgement operates freely, neither softened by the beauty, nor awed by the dignity of his thoughts; but such is the power of his poetry… Milton’s style was not modified by his subject … One source of his peculiarity was his familiarity with the Tuscan poets: the disposition of his words is, I think, frequently Italian; "

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
8/8/25Samuel JohnsonThe Lives of English Poets5601779Non-FictionN/AN/A
9/1/26Peter MurphyThrough the Heretical Lens (1)1922026Non-Fiction7.9507.722
about Milton
6/22/26W.B.C WatkinsAn Anatomy of Milton's Verse1461955Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
5/27/26John PeterA Critique of Paradise Lost1721970Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
5/18/26C.S. LewisA Preface to Paradise Lost1431942Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
3/12/26F.T. PrinceThe Italian Element in Milton's Verse2081962Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
3/10/26Douglas BushParadise Lost in our Time1171957Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
3/8/26E.M.Y. TillyardStudies in Milton1761973Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
2/17/26Isabel MacCaffrey Paradise Lost as “Myth”2291959Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
2/15/26Walter Curry ClydeMilton's Ontology Cosmogony and Physics2261957Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
2/6/26Williiam KerriganThe Sacred Complex2981983Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
1/27/26Thomas KranidasThe Fierce Equation1581965Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
1/24/26James WhalerCounterpoint and Symbol2261956Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
1/22/26Malcom RossPoetry & dogma2561954Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
1/18/26George ConklinBiblical Criticism and Heresy in Milton1371971Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
1/11/26Michael LiebThe Dialectics of Creation: Patterns of Birth & Regeneration2441969Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
1/8/26William G. MadsenFrom Shadowy Types to Truth2021967Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
1/5/26William EmpsonMilton's God2761961Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
12/18/25John MiltonDe Doctrina Christiana5641645Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
12/8/25Harold BloomThe Western Canon5281994Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
9/21/25Stanley FishSurprised by Sin: the Reader in Paradise Lost3641967Non-Fiction7.0006.667
about Milton
9/18/25Geoffrey HartmanA Critic's Journey: Literary Reflections3401998Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
9/15/25Louis Martz20th Century Views: Milton, Paradise Lost: A Collection of Essays2091966Non-Fiction7.7507.500
about Milton
8/2/25Balachandra RajanParadise Lost and the Seventeenth Century Reader1761947Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
7/30/25John MiltonAreopagitica and Other Political Writings of John Milton4721644Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
7/30/25A.J.A. WaldockParadise Lost: And Its Critics1601961Non-FictionN/AN/A
about Milton
9/16/26Herman MelvilleMoby Dick6081851Fiction8.4508.278
Gam/lackthereof
Howarddd
7/5/26William HayleyThe Life of Milton: Conjectures on the origin of Paradise Lost3381799BiographyN/AN/A
about Milton
3/9/26David Masson1608-1639
The Life of John Milton (1)
8741881BiographyN/AN/A
about Milton
3/9/26David Masson1638-1642
The Life of John Milton (2)
1501881BiographyN/AN/A
about Milton
2/20/26Rufus JonesSpiritual Reformers of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries3511911HistoryN/AN/A
about Milton
11/15/25John MiltonEpistolæ Familiares1141674EpistlesN/AN/A
about Milton
11/10/26Pope Leo XIVI Am a Son of Saint Augustine1042026Non-Fiction7.2506.944
7/3/26Arthur SewellA Study in Milton's Christian Doctrine2141939Non-Fiction8.7508.611
4/16/26Bronze Age PervertBronze Age Mindset1982018Non-Fiction5.0004.444
4/3/26Mel RobbinsThe Let Them Theory3362024Non-Fiction6.0005.556
3/2/26Philippa SnowWhich as You Know Means Violence1202022Non-Fiction7.8757.639
2/22/26Denys TurnerThe Darkness of God: Negativity in Christian Mysticism2921998Non-Fiction7.7507.500
8/3/24Kim ZetterCountdown to Zero Day4062014Non-Fiction7.2506.944
7/2/23Samo BurjaThe Great Founder Theory1772020Non-Fiction6.7506.389
roon
2/2/23Peter LeesonThe Invisible Hook2882009Non-Fiction7.5007.222
Misha
4/10/22William JamesThe Varieties of Religious Experience2841902Non-Fiction7.5007.222
11/20/21Robert ReichJust Giving2562020Non-Fiction6.7506.389
10/15/18Bart D. EhrmanA Historical Introduction to the Early Christian Writings6082011Non-Fiction8.5008.333
7/14/17Robert GatesA Passion for Leadership2562016Non-Fiction8.0007.778
6/29/17Christopher McDougallBorn to Run3062009Non-Fiction7.7507.500
6/14/17Aleksandr SolzhenitsynThe Gulag Archipelago5281973Non-Fiction7.7507.500
9/26/16Martin PopsThe Metamorphosis of Shit361982Non-Fiction8.5008.333
8/14/15Marcus LuttrellLone Survivor3902007Non-Fiction7.2506.944