murphyandhislaw

reading list

Wittgenstein's Mistress

David Markson

published: 1988, read: 11/10/25
248 pages, genre: Fiction
rating: 8.25/10, normalized: 8.056/10
0.904σ better than average
0.949σ or 1.027/10 better than average in Fiction genre
0.313σ or 0.313/10 better than average recommended by Dasha
Recommended by: Dasha

The first chapter starts off with a soliloquy from the narrating protagonist who is a bat shit insane woman who has been running around the entire world in some sort of fugue state ("time out of mind"). When we encounter her, she is living on the beach in the second house, because she burnt the first one down on accident.

So far, the only other living person that she's mentioned it's not even living. It's her deceased child whose grave she visited in Mexico, but it kind of sounds like this might be a post apocalyptic setting, and she is so singularly charged with remembering all of culture hence her obsession with art and literature.

Her disregard for safety and property and her reliance on surviving without devices that provide shelter or heat does reinforce the idea that she might be the last person alive. It would also explain her removed and apathetic sense of remembrance towards the name of her husband and her son, whose name is she interchanges (Simon (S) and Adam (H)). She mentions how some old habits die hard, and for example, mentions how she will occasionally drive on the British side of the road. This is not something that you can do if there are other people or not driving on the right side of the road.

We don't even learn that her name is Kate until the second or third chapter – identity of self/other real people (not authors or painters or musicians) fall by the wayside.

Sounds like he was having an affair with some guy named Terry (later Luciene), and there were probably others too. This comes up through her recollection of a admonishment from her mother who calls her a young silly girl.

Need to read more Wittgenstein in order to verify, but there are certain stylistic cues that seem intentionally stilted, probably imitating his style of writing. Such as lapsing between first person pronouns, and then the impersonal third person pronoun "one" when using about things that she, Kate, is definitely the one musing about. Additionally, using, "however," and "apologies," for a very jarring transition phrase. See also "doubtless"

Lots of stilted monologues (the whole book consists of these throughout which are interwoven glimpses into the world she lives in)

There was an X. Actually, there was only almost an X however. This is somehow similar to a 123, have I mentioned that I do love 123? I do a 123 actually it's only just almost 123.

Kate states some connection that Lucien is the first of her lovers that she has told us about, but this is not true since we already know that she was recommended by her mother for having an affair with Terry who we also know was not the first. So it seems as though Kate's own recollection is flawed.

Other details she gets wrong or contradict herself, establishing herself as an unreliable narrator, stating that the cat was orange and this comes out of nowhere. Well after the description of the cat she ran into at the Colosseum. And then two chapters later she says no I'm sure the cat is black. She doesn't even say "no, I was wrong not orange but black," admitting that it's something that she's told us about already, she just introduces it as if it's new additional fact, not a piece of information to be held in tension against everything else that we've heard from her so far because it reinforces the fact that she is unreliable.

At some point, admittedly, probably far too long into the book, do I begin to wonder how the hell she braved the Atlantic. It sounds as though she went from Mexico to somewhere in Texas and then up through Alaska then through Russia while she thought it was China finally to Greece and then set up shop in London and Rome and France. But I can't imagine that she drove all that way. Maybe she did. She also stayed in Soho and somewhere in Pennsylvania, so she's really just painting a map of the United States on her travels. Unclear at what time everybody else disappeared from the world, but if she's driving all this distance and staying in these places for long enough to burn down some houses and do lots of reading aloud and eventually burning those places in those pages as well, it sounds like on the order of years like tens of years.

Perhaps they have not invented baseball at the time is just a hilarious thought for this woman to have. Fully embracing her femininity.

Another book which, like Stoner, sounds droll in its description but has such rich texture and is a celebration of a very specific idea. In the same way that I found it impossible to describe The Unbearable Lightness of Being without it sounding incredibly dull, this book would sound incredibly pretentious. However, I think the unique voice of the protagonist and the recurrence of and reliance upon mythology and artists and musicians looking from trivia rather than the things that they might commonly be known for as well as the constant second-guessing about the assurance of those facts, which is definitely intentional, doesn't make it seem as though references to those things he's trying to impress upon the reader house part the author is your house smart the speaker is, it's just like.

The fact that they never get around to naming the cat that she and her son had and always only ever called the "cat" seems like the truest name that you could give such a thing, I'm not sure if Wittgenstein speaks of this, but I suspect that he does.

Contrast with an earlier anecdote about how Rembrandt's students in his workshop write or draw or paint images of gold coins on the floor that were so convincing that he would stoop over to try to pick them up. This is an illusion of meaning, which had no effect on cats because they don't understand currency, and if they did, they probably wouldn't care either. So in some sense, the cat does not care about its own name, so call a cat. The cat is the most accurate thing that you can do, but there's still probably a fundamental breakdown meaning of the construct of animals species.

Additionally, there's a really funny implication that the tortoise from Zeno paradox is faster than Hector because while Achilles never catches up to the tortoise, Achilles does catch up to Hector and kill him.

Confuses the name of her son, which is Simon not to be confused with the name of the father Paul (or Adam) with the name of the man with whom she was having an affair, Luciene, this comes out when she's describing who's responsibility was to name the cat and she said it was four-year-old Lucien's immediately after describing the man with whom she was having an affair also by that same name. These kinds of lapses in memory be the question if the whole book is supposed to be an indictment of analytic philosophy, or maybe just specific theories, while still celebrating his [W's] ideas through the emulation of his tone. The fact that she can't keep straight the things which really auto to matter to her like the name of her son let alone the name of her son's cat, can one reason herself to any sort of meaningful conclusions from first principles alone in isolation? No woman is an Island.

It is implied that her son died while she was having an affair (like literally while she was having an affair) with another man, and her still-husband at the time Adam got drunk and didn't call a doctor. The actual details surrounding her son's death are ambiguous, but the conflation of her son's name with the name of her lover, who she was saying while he was dying is speak volumes. She immediately revises this order of events, saying, of course, none of this happened given that we were both there that weekend, and neither of us could've done anything at all, after musing about which came first the husband getting drunk because of the affair or the affair happening because of the husband's insistence on getting drunk.

Paraphrasing, imagine how a heroine would feel if she awoke on some Wednesday or Thursday, utterly alone in the world. Not even a seagull, just vegetables and plants. She doesn't mention that there would be cats, also this comes towards the end of the book as an introduction, explaining what's been going on this far, though I think it should be straightforward to peace together what's happening after the second chapter. Kate continues to muse about the merits of such an autobiographical novel where the woman would gradually come to realize that she had always been alone just as much as she was now at the point of composing the autobiography in a world where everyone else is gone, and there would not be much to do other than be angry at home though, and then write nonsense Greek in the sand and burn the occasional house down

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
11/10/25David MarksonWittgenstein's Mistress2481988Fiction8.2508.056
Dasha
8/6/25Christina Brooke-RoseAmalgamemnon1521984Fiction7.2506.944
soliloquyobsessed with Greece
Dasha
3/19/26David Foster WallaceThe Broom of the System4671987Fiction7.8757.639
Wittgenstein
2/28/26Lucy EllmannDucks, Newburyport10222019Fiction2.0001.111
soliloquy
1/30/26William H. GassThe Tunnel6521995Fiction8.5508.389
schizo
Ben Roth
1/25/26Jacqueline HarpmanI Who Have Never Known Men1841995Fiction6.8506.500
Last woman alive
Jessika
1/24/26Jon FosseThe Other Name
Septology (1)
3512019Fiction6.5006.111
schizo
12/23/25Sally RooneyIntermezzo4482024Fiction7.8507.611
Wittgenstein
10/22/25Milan KunderaThe Unbearable Lightness of Being3141984Fiction8.2008.000
Quiet classic
Ben Roth
10/9/25Vigdis HjorthWill and Testament3362016Fiction8.0007.778
Quiet classic
9/29/25John WilliamsStoner2781965Fiction8.2508.056
Quiet classic
8/5/25Roberto BolañoBy Night in Chile1182000Fiction7.2506.944
soliloquy
4/18/25Vladimir NabokovThe Luzhin Defense2801930Fiction7.8507.611
schizo
10/18/24John Kennedy TooleA Confederacy of Dunces4051980Fiction7.7507.500
schizo
Tommy A.
10/1/24Fyodor DostoevskyCrime and Punishment5271866Fiction7.2866.984
referenced
Tommy A.
6/26/24VariousAmerican Short Fiction Vol. 9, Issue 331282006Fiction7.6257.361
schizo
5/17/24Neil GaimanAmerican Gods5182001Fiction5.1254.583
mythology
Nick W.
3/10/18Virginia WoolfMrs. Dalloway2241925Fiction6.5006.111
schizo
Steg
10/10/16William FaulknerThe Sound and the Fury3261927Fiction8.2508.056
schizo
Steg
9/11/14Guy De MaupassantThe Prisoners241880Fiction7.5007.222
referenced
2/19/26Ed AtkinsFlower962025Biography7.0006.667
soliloquy
6/18/25Brian ReedS-Town2542017Biography6.3215.913
schizo
Jessika
3/22/25Steven HallThe Raw Shark Texts4282007Ergodic7.6887.431
schizo
8/16/24David MazzucchelliAsterios Polyp3462009Graphic Novel9.2509.167
mythology
7/16/24Mark Z. DanielewskiHouse of Leaves, 2nd Ed.7092000Ergodic10.00010.000
schizo
5/1/23Ada PalmerPerhaps the Stars
Terra Ignota (4)
8542021Sci-Fantasy9.5009.444
mythology
roon
6/25/19Douglas HofstatderI am a Strange Loop4122007Psychology8.5008.333
mental models
7/14/16Henry NeffThe Second Siege
Tapestry (2)
5122008Fantasy7.5007.222
mythology
Charlie J.
3/4/16Michael ScottThe Enchantress
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (6)
4162012Fantasy7.2506.944
mythology
2/2/16Michael ScottThe Warlock
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (5)
4002011Fantasy7.5007.222
mythology
11/10/15Michael ScottThe Necromancer
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (4)
4162010Fantasy7.5007.222
mythology
4/20/15Michael ScottThe Sorceress
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (3)
4832009Fantasy7.0006.667
mythology
3/13/15Michael ScottThe Magician
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (2)
4612008Fantasy7.0006.667
mythology
7/15/14Michael ScottThe Alchemist
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (1)
3752007Fantasy6.7506.389
mythology
11/13/26Donna TarttThe Secret History5591992Fiction8.0007.778
Kayla
10/22/26Yu MiriTokyo Ueno Station1922021Fiction6.0005.556
10/21/26Don DeLilloMao II2561992Fiction8.0007.778
10/16/26Mikhail LermontovA Hero of Our Time2081840Fiction7.4507.167
Zack B.
10/12/26Fyodor DostoevskyWhite Nights961848Fiction6.5006.111
Taylor R.
10/6/26Rohinton MistryA Fine Balance6241995Fiction7.6507.389
Kayla
10/4/26Don DeLilloPafko at the Wall962001Fiction7.2506.944
9/25/26William GaddisCarpenter's Gothic2881985Fiction8.5008.333
9/24/26Osamu DazaiNo Longer Human1771948Fiction7.6507.389
9/16/26Herman MelvilleMoby Dick6081851Fiction8.4508.278
Howarddd
9/7/26Don DeLilloWhite Noise3201985Fiction7.7507.500
Ben Roth
9/5/26John WilliamsNothing but the Night1441948Fiction7.3507.056
8/26/26Stefan ZweigBeware of Pity3921939Fiction7.8507.611
8/18/26Miroslav KrležaOn the Edge of Reason1921938Fiction7.8507.611
8/13/26Cormac McCarthyCities of the Plain
The Border Trilogy (3)
2921998Fiction7.7507.500
8/10/26Cormac McCarthyThe Crossing
The Border Trilogy (2)
4261994Fiction7.5007.222
8/6/26Cormac McCarthyAll the Pretty Horses
The Border Trilogy (1)
3021992Fiction7.6257.361
8/4/26Ray BradburyThere Will Come Soft Rains51950Fiction6.7506.389
7/31/26Mikhail BulgakovHeart of a Dog 1231968Fiction7.3507.056
Zack B.
7/29/26Min Jin LeePachinko5442017Fiction6.5836.204
7/20/26Thomas MannThe Magic Mountain7061924Fiction7.3007.000
Scott
6/28/26Ivan TurgenevFathers and Sons2261862Fiction7.0006.667
Scott
6/6/26Mikhail BulgakovThe Master and Margarita4501967Fiction7.6507.389
5/5/26Brian EvensonAltmann's Tongue2781994Fiction6.5006.111
5/1/26Laura Knowlinif only i had told her3912024Fiction6.0335.593
4/27/26Jean RaspailThe Camp of the Saints3561973Fiction5.5005.000
4/22/26Virginia WoolfTo the Lighthouse2091927Fiction7.3507.056
Ben Roth
4/19/26Benjamín LabatutWhen We Cease to Understand the World1922021Fiction8.0007.778
4/18/26László KrasznahorkaiChasing Homer962019Fiction6.6506.278
4/17/26Cormac McCarthyNo Country for Old Men3202005Fiction8.2508.056
4/13/26Cormac McCarthyBlood Meridian3491985Fiction8.6508.500
4/11/26Patrick WhiteVoss4421957Fiction7.6507.389
4/5/26John WilliamsAugustus3361971Fiction8.2508.056
4/5/26Joseph AndrasTomorrow They Won't Dare to Murder Us1442021Fiction8.0007.778
4/2/26Roberto BolañoPosthumous Stories1602025Fiction7.0006.667
4/2/26SophoclesOedipus Rex94-429Fiction7.0006.667
4/1/26Makenna GoodmanHelen of Nowhere1602025Fiction7.3507.056
3/31/26Roberto BolañoThe Return2082010Fiction7.1156.795
3/27/26Roberto BolañoThe Third Reich2771989Fiction7.7507.500
3/25/26Roberto BolañoNazi Literature in the Americas2371996Fiction8.2508.056
3/23/26Roberto BolañoThe Skating Rink1921993Fiction7.3507.056
3/22/26Roberto BolañoThe Insufferable Gaucho1642003Fiction7.6257.361
3/21/26Roberto BolañoA Little Lumpen Novelita1282002Fiction7.5507.278
3/20/26Roberto BolañoAntwerp1192002Fiction7.2506.944
3/14/26Alexis WrightPraiseworthy7362023Fiction7.1256.806
3/4/26André GideThe Immoralist1541902Fiction7.0006.667
Ben Roth
3/3/26Stefan ZweigChess841942Fiction8.5008.333
2/16/26Natsuo KirinoOut4161992Fiction5.0004.444
1/25/26Jon FosseA New Name
Septology (3)
2282021Fiction7.0006.667
1/24/26Jon FosseI is Another
Septology (2)
2712020Fiction6.8336.481
1/20/26John WilliamsButcher's Crossing2741960Fiction7.7507.500
1/19/26Raymond CarverWhat We Talk About When We Talk About Love1761981Fiction6.5006.111
1/18/26Sally RooneyBeautiful World, Where Are You3682021Fiction6.2505.833
Kayla
1/1/26Juan RulfoPedro Páramo1441955Fiction7.8507.611
12/26/25Boris and Arkady StrugatskyOne Billion Years to the End of the World1761977Fiction7.4507.167
11/27/25Vladimir SorokinTheir Four Hearts2041994Fiction7.5007.222
10/15/25Louis-Ferdinand CélineGuignol's Band2871944Fiction6.0005.556
10/12/25László KrasznahorkaiSátántangó3331985Fiction7.8507.611
10/2/25Brett Easton EllisThe Informers2401994Fiction7.0006.667
9/18/25Fyodor DostoevskyPoor Folk2881846Fiction6.7506.389
Tommy A.
9/16/25David Foster WallaceBrief Interviews with Hideous Men2881999Fiction8.6338.481
9/4/25Sue Monk KiddThe Book of Longings4322020Fiction6.3505.944
8/25/25Roberto BolañoAmulet1541999Fiction7.0006.667
8/9/25Toni MorrisonSong of Solomon3381977Fiction7.3507.056
Ben Roth
8/7/25Roberto BolañoMonsieur Pain1341999Fiction8.1007.889
8/6/25Denis JohnsonTrain Dreams1162002Fiction7.4507.167
Ben Roth
8/5/25Thomas PynchonThe Crying of Lot 491521965Fiction8.7508.611
Preston
8/3/25Roberto BolañoThe Savage Detectives6561998Fiction7.1676.852
Dasha
7/31/25William FaulknerAs I Lay Dying2881930Fiction7.7507.500
Dasha
7/14/25Mark Z. DanielewskiThe Fifty Year Sword2802005Fiction5.5005.000
7/11/25Vladimir NabokovThe Enchanter1441986Fiction7.7507.500
7/10/25Vladimir NabokovLook at the Harlequins!2241974Fiction8.2868.095
7/7/25Vladimir NabokovNabokov's Dozen2141958Fiction6.6356.261
7/7/25Vladimir NabokovTransparent Things1271972Fiction8.2508.056
7/4/25Dino BuzzatiThe Tartar Steppe1981940Fiction7.6507.389
Ben Roth
6/24/25Vladimir NabokovAda or Ardor: A Family Chronicle5001969Fiction6.5506.167
6/19/25Vladimir NabokovPnin2081957Fiction7.6507.389
6/9/25Vladimir NabokovBend Sinister2721947Fiction7.2506.944
6/7/25Vladimir NabokovThe Gift3841938Fiction6.2505.833
6/3/25Vladimir NabokovInvitation to a Beheading2401936Fiction7.5007.222
5/31/25Gillian FlynnSharp Objects2522006Fiction7.0006.667
5/31/25Vladimir NabokovLaughter in the Dark3041933Fiction7.3507.056
5/27/25Hubert Selby Jr.Last Exit to Brooklyn3201964Fiction8.7088.565
King
5/24/25Herman MelvilleBartleby the Scrivener741853Fiction7.0006.667
Ben Roth
5/9/25Vladimir NabokovKing, Queen, Knave2721928Fiction7.6007.333
5/9/25Vladimir NabokovThe Eye1281930Fiction6.5006.111
5/8/25Vladimir NabokovMary1441926Fiction7.2506.944
4/20/25Vladimir NabokovGlory2241932Fiction6.7506.389
4/19/25Vladimir NabokovDespair2401934Fiction7.0006.667
4/18/25Jane AustenSense and Sensibility4321811Fiction7.7507.500
Emma
4/15/25David Foster WallaceThe Pale King6362011Fiction7.7507.500
4/14/25Elisa Shua DusapinThe Pachinko Parlor1642018Fiction7.8507.611
2/7/25James JoyceUlysses7321920Fiction8.1817.978
1/30/25Leo TolstoyThe Death of Ivan Ilyich1281886Fiction6.7506.389
King
1/29/25Hubert Selby Jr.Requiem for a Dream2881978Fiction7.5007.222
1/21/25Kaveh AkbarMartyr!3522024Fiction7.7507.500
Tommy A.
1/14/25James BaldwinGo Tell it on the Mountain2721952Fiction8.0007.778
1/12/25James BaldwinIf Beale Street Could Talk1971974Fiction6.2505.833
1/10/25James BaldwinGiovanni's Room1591956Fiction6.5006.111
1/10/25Anthony BurgessA Clockwork Orange2431962Fiction7.5007.222
1/4/25Khaled HosseiniKite Runner3712003Fiction6.7506.389
12/26/24Fyodor DostoevskyNotes from Underground1681864Fiction7.5007.222
Tommy A.
12/10/24Neal StephensonZodiac3161988Fiction7.0006.667
11/6/24Fyodor DostoevskyThe Gambler1911866Fiction6.5006.111
11/5/24Fyodor DostoevskyThe Double1441846Fiction6.2505.833
10/30/24David Foster WallaceInfinite Jest14511996Fiction10.00010.000
10/25/24Vladimir NabokovThe Real Life of Sebastian Knight2361941Fiction7.1506.833
10/25/24Various40 x 403942003Fiction7.5007.222
10/20/24Fyodor DostoevskyThe Idiot4861869Fiction7.1256.806
Tommy A.
10/13/24Italo CalvinoInvisible Cities1791972Fiction5.5005.000
9/30/24Jorge Luis BorgesThe Zahir131949Fiction7.2506.944
9/26/24Haruki MurakamiKafka on the Shore5052002Fiction5.8755.417
9/25/24Franz KafkaIn the Penal Colony331919Fiction7.5007.222
9/25/24Ray BradburyThe Veldt131950Fiction6.5006.111
9/19/24William FaulknerLight in August4981932Fiction7.3507.056
9/9/24Thomas PynchonV.5451963Fiction7.2216.912
8/14/24Fyodor DostoevskyThe Brothers Karamazov8981880Fiction8.6548.504
Tommy A.
8/5/24Brian O'RaleighPassage to Inis Mór3052020Fiction7.7507.500
Grandpa
6/28/24Te-Ping ChenThe Land of Big Numbers2362021Fiction5.6255.139
6/20/24James JoyceA Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man2991916Fiction6.5006.111
6/7/24Philip RothEveryman1932006Fiction4.5003.889
6/6/24Jorge Luis BorgesTlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius161940Fiction7.7507.500
Chabon
6/3/24Cormac McCarthyThe Road2572006Fiction7.5007.222
Chabon
5/30/24Vladimir NabokovLolita3361955Fiction8.2138.014
4/9/24Roberto Bolaño2666: A Novel9122004Fiction8.1507.944
roon
3/21/24John SteinbeckEast of Eden6011952Fiction8.6888.542
Jack H.
2/19/24Ray BradburyMars is Heaven121948Fiction8.0007.778
9/1/23Máirtín Ó CadhainGraveyard Clay3281949Fiction6.7506.389
12/13/22Adam SilveraThey Both Die at the End2432017Fiction2.0001.111
7/25/22Ray BradburyThe Illustrated Man2561969Fiction7.5007.222
6/13/22Stephen KingThe Institute5762019Fiction6.5006.111
6/12/19Stephen KingThe Stand11531978Fiction8.5008.333
Dad
4/20/18Anthony PowellThe Acceptance World
A Dance to the Music of Time (3)
3531955Fiction6.7506.389
Steg
4/17/18Anthony PowellA Buyer's Market
A Dance to the Music of Time (2)
2921952Fiction6.7506.389
Steg
4/15/18Anthony PowellA Question of Upbringing
A Dance to the Music of Time (1)
2301951Fiction6.7506.389
Steg
11/12/17Kazuo IshiguroNever Let Me Go3042005Fiction4.0003.333
10/15/17William GoldingLord of the Flies1891954Fiction7.0006.667
9/1/17Hunter S. ThompsonFear and Loathing in Las Vegas2251971Fiction6.0005.556
Alex W.
8/12/17Kurt VonnegutSlaughterhouse Five1901969Fiction7.7507.500
Sean G.
6/21/17Fredrik BackmanAnd Every Morning the Way Home Gets Longer and Longer962016Fiction9.0008.889
Mom
5/27/17Franz KafkaThe Trial1501925Fiction7.5007.222
2/15/17Frank O'ConnorThe Drunkard61948Fiction8.0007.778
10/20/16Charles DickensA Tale of Two Cities5441859Fiction6.7506.389
5/20/16J.D. SalingerCatcher in the Rye2321951Fiction3.0002.222
5/20/16Kurt VonengutTimequake2782011Fiction8.2508.056
Sean G.
3/15/13Richard ConnellThe Most Dangerous Game181924Fiction7.2506.944
Mom